Bills · 2019-2020 Regular Session
Relating to: requirements for children born alive following abortion or attempted abortion and providing a penalty.
Abortion Crime and criminals Crime and criminals — Felony Damage personal injury Fines Hospitals and health care facilities Legislature — Criminal penalties joint review committee on Nurses Physician
- Introduced, completed
- Passes Assembly, completed
- Passes Senate, stopped here
- Governor signs, not reached
- Law, not reached
Unfamiliar terms? Glossary
What this bill does
Plain-language analysis by the nonpartisan Legislative Reference Bureau
This bill requires any health care provider present at the time an abortion or
attempted abortion results in a child born alive to exercise the same degree of
professional skill, care, and diligence to preserve the life and health of the child as
a reasonably diligent and conscientious health care provider would render to any
other child born alive at the same gestational age and to ensure that the child born
alive is immediately transported and admitted to a hospital. A health care provider
or an employee of a hospital, physician's office, or clinic where abortions are
performed or induced who has knowledge of a failure to comply with the
requirements of the bill must immediately report the failure to an appropriate law
enforcement agency. Any person who violates the requirement to exercise
professional skill, care, and diligence or to ensure the child is transported and
admitted to a hospital is guilty of a felony with a penalty of a fine not to exceed
$10,000, imprisonment not to exceed six years, or both. The mother of the child born
alive, however, may not be prosecuted. This bill specifies that a woman upon whom
an abortion was performed or attempted may bring a claim for damages, including
damages for personal injury and emotional and psychological distress, against a
person who violates or attempts to violate the requirements of the bill.
The bill also makes intentionally causing the death of a child born alive as a
result of an abortion or an attempted abortion a felony with a penalty of life
imprisonment, which is the same penalty as first-degree intentional homicide. The
mother of the child born alive may not be prosecuted under this provision in the bill.
Under current law, an individual who undergoes a live birth is considered born
alive. “Live birth” is defined as the complete expulsion or extraction from his or her
mother, of a human being, at any stage of development, who, after the expulsion or
extraction, breathes or has a beating heart, pulsation of the umbilical cord, or
definite movement of voluntary muscles, regardless of whether the umbilical cord
has been cut and whether the expulsion or extraction occurs as a result of natural
or induced labor, a cesarean section, or an abortion. Under current law, whoever is
born alive as a result of an abortion is considered to have the same legal status and
legal rights as a human being at any point after the human being undergoes a live
birth as the result of natural or induced labor or a cesarean section.
Because this bill creates a new crime or revises a penalty for an existing crime,
the Joint Review Committee on Criminal Penalties may be requested to prepare a
report.
Sponsors
Introduced by: Allen (R) , August (R) , Ballweg (R) , Born (R) , Brooks (R) , Dittrich (R) , Duchow (R) , Edming (R) , Felzkowski (R) , Gundrum (R) , Horlacher (R) , Hutton (R) , Jagler (R) , James (R) , Katsma (R) , Kerkman (R) , Kitchens (R) , Knodl (R) , Krug (R) , Kuglitsch (R) , Kulp (R) , Kurtz (R) , Loudenbeck (R) , Macco (R) , Magnafici (R) , Murphy (R) , Mursau (R) , Neylon (R) , Novak (R) , Nygren (R) , Oldenburg (R) , Ott (R) , Petersen (R) , Petryk (R) , Plumer (R) , Pronschinske (R) , Quinn (R) , Ramthun (R) , Rodriguez (R) , Rohrkaste (R) , Sanfelippo (R) , Schraa (R) , Skowronski (R) , Snyder (R) , Sortwell (R) , Spiros (R) , Stafsholt (R) , Steffen (R) , Steineke (R) , Summerfield (R) , Swearingen (R) , Tauchen (R) , Thiesfeldt (R) , Tittl (R) , Tranel (R) , Tusler (R) , VanderMeer (R) , Vorpagel (R) , Vos (R) , Wittke (R) , Zimmerman (R)
Votes
Assembly: Report passage recommended by Committee on Health, Ayes 8, Noes 5
Passed 8–5 May 9, 2019 official source full pageNo individual roll call was recorded for this vote. Committee votes and some older sessions record totals only.
Aye · 62
- Adam Neylon (15)
- Amy Loudenbeck (31)
- Barbara Dittrich (99)
- Bob Kulp (69)
- Bob Wittke (63)
- Cindi Duchow (97)
- Cody Horlacher (33)
- Dan Knodl (24)
- Dave Murphy (56)
- David Steffen (4)
- Gae Magnafici (28)
- Gary Tauchen (6)
- James Edming (87)
- Janel Brandtjen (22)
- Jeff Mursau (36)
- Jeremy Thiesfeldt (52)
- Jesse James (23)
- Jessie Rodriguez (21)
- Jim Ott (23)
- Jim Steineke (5)
- Joan Ballweg (14)
- Joe Sanfelippo (15)
- Joel Kitchens (1)
- John Jagler (13)
- John Macco (88)
- John Nygren (89)
- John Spiros (86)
- Jon Plumer (42)
- Ken Skowronski (82)
- Kevin Petersen (57)
- Loren Oldenburg (96)
- Mark Born (37)
- Mary Felzkowski (12)
- Michael Schraa (53)
- Mike Kuglitsch (84)
- Mike Rohrkaste (55)
- Nancy VanderMeer (70)
- Pat Snyder (85)
- Paul Tittl (25)
- Rick Gundrum (58)
- Rob Brooks (59)
- Rob Hutton (5)
- Rob Stafsholt (10)
- Rob Summerfield (68)
- Rob Swearingen (34)
- Robin Vos (33)
- Romaine Quinn (25)
- Ron Tusler (3)
- Samantha Kerkman (61)
- Scott Allen (82)
- Scott Krug (72)
- Shae Sortwell (2)
- Shannon Zimmerman (30)
- Terry Katsma (26)
- Timothy Ramthun (59)
- Todd Novak (51)
- Tony Kurtz (41)
- Travis Tranel (49)
- Treig Pronschinske (29)
- Tyler August (31)
- Tyler Vorpagel (27)
- Warren Petryk (93)
Nay · 35
- Amanda Stuck (57)
- Beth Meyers (74)
- Chris Taylor (76)
- Christine Sinicki (20)
- Chuck Wichgers (84)
- Daniel Riemer (7)
- Dave Considine (81)
- David Bowen (10)
- David Crowley (17)
- Debra Kolste (44)
- Dianne Hesselbein (27)
- Don Vruwink (43)
- Evan Goyke (18)
- Gary Hebl (46)
- Gordon Hintz (54)
- Greta Neubauer (66)
- Jason Fields (11)
- Jill Billings (95)
- Jimmy Anderson (47)
- JoCasta Zamarripa (8)
- Jodi Emerson (91)
- Jonathan Brostoff (19)
- Kalan Haywood (16)
- Katrina Shankland (71)
- Lisa Subeck (79)
- Mark Spreitzer (15)
- Melissa Sargent (48)
- Nick Milroy (73)
- Robyn Vining (13)
- Shelia Stubbs (78)
- Sondy Pope (80)
- Staush Gruszynski (90)
- Steve Doyle (94)
- Tip McGuire (64)
- Tod Ohnstad (65)
Not voting · 2
- LaKeshia Myers (12)
- Marisabel Cabrera (9)
Senate: Public hearing requirement waived by committee on Senate Organization, pursuant to Senate Rule 18 (1m), Ayes 3, Noes 2
Passed 3–2 Jun 3, 2019 official source full pageNo individual roll call was recorded for this vote. Committee votes and some older sessions record totals only.
Aye · 18
- Alberta Darling (8)
- Chris Kapenga (33)
- Dale Kooyenga (5)
- Dan Feyen (20)
- David Craig (28)
- Devin LeMahieu (9)
- Duey Stroebel (20)
- Howard Marklein (17)
- Jerry Petrowski (29)
- Kathleen Bernier (23)
- Luther S. Olsen (14)
- Patrick Testin (24)
- Rob Cowles (2)
- Roger Roth (19)
- Scott L. Fitzgerald (13)
- Steve Nass (11)
- Thomas Tiffany (12)
- Van Wanggaard (21)
Nay · 14
- André Jacque (1)
- Bob Wirch (22)
- Dave Hansen (30)
- Fred A. Risser (26)
- Janet Bewley (25)
- Janis Ringhand (15)
- Jeff Smith (31)
- Jennifer Shilling (32)
- Jon Erpenbach (27)
- LaTonya Johnson (6)
- Lena Taylor (4)
- Mark Miller (16)
- Patty Schachtner (10)
- Tim Carpenter (3)
Not voting · 1
- Chris Larson (7)
Full history
- Apr 18, 2019 · Assembly
Introduced by Representatives Steineke, Vos, Allen, August, Ballweg, Born, Brooks, Dittrich, Duchow, Edming, Felzkowski, Gundrum, Horlacher, Hutton, Jagler, James, Katsma, Kerkman, Kitchens, Knodl, Krug, Kuglitsch, Kulp, Kurtz, Loudenbeck, Macco, Magnafici, Murphy, Mursau, Neylon, Novak, Nygren, Oldenburg, Ott, Petersen, Petryk, Plumer, Pronschinske, Quinn, Ramthun, Rodriguez, Rohrkaste, Sanfelippo, Schraa, Skowronski, Snyder, Sortwell, Spiros, Stafsholt, Steffen, Summerfield, Swearingen, Tauchen, Thiesfeldt, Tittl, Tranel, Tusler, VanderMeer, Vorpagel, Wittke and Zimmerman; cosponsored by Senators Roth, Fitzgerald, Bernier, Cowles, Craig, Darling, Feyen, Kapenga, Kooyenga, LeMahieu, Marklein, Nass, Olsen, Petrowski, Stroebel, Testin, Tiffany and Wanggaard
- Apr 18, 2019 · Assembly
Read first time and referred to Committee on Health
- May 7, 2019 · Assembly
Assembly Amendment 1 offered by Representative Wichgers
- May 7, 2019 · Assembly
Public hearing held
- May 9, 2019 · Assembly
Executive action taken
- May 9, 2019 · Assembly
Report passage recommended by Committee on Health, Ayes 8, Noes 5
- May 9, 2019 · Assembly
Referred to committee on Rules
- May 9, 2019 · Assembly
Placed on calendar 5-15-2019 by Committee on Rules
- May 15, 2019 · Assembly
Rules suspended
- May 15, 2019 · Assembly
Read a third time and passed, Ayes 62, Noes 35
- May 15, 2019 · Assembly
Ordered immediately messaged
- May 15, 2019 · Assembly
Read a second time
- May 15, 2019 · Assembly
Ordered to a third reading
- May 16, 2019 · Senate
Received from Assembly
- May 16, 2019 · Senate
Read first time and referred to committee on Senate Organization
- May 16, 2019 · Senate
Available for scheduling
- May 23, 2019 · Senate
Senate Amendment 1 offered by Senator Jacque
- Jun 3, 2019 · Senate
Public hearing requirement waived by committee on Senate Organization, pursuant to Senate Rule 18 (1m), Ayes 3, Noes 2
- Jun 3, 2019 · Senate
Placed on calendar 6-5-2019 pursuant to Senate Rule 18(1)
- Jun 5, 2019 · Senate
Read a second time
- Jun 5, 2019 · Senate
Senate Amendment 1 withdrawn and returned to author
- Jun 5, 2019 · Senate
Ordered to a third reading
- Jun 5, 2019 · Senate
Rules suspended
- Jun 5, 2019 · Senate
Read a third time and concurred in, Ayes 18, Noes 14
- Jun 5, 2019 · Senate
Ordered immediately messaged
- Jun 5, 2019 · Assembly
Received from Senate concurred in
- Jun 6, 2019 · Assembly
Report correctly enrolled on 6-6-2019
- Jun 20, 2019 · Assembly
Presented to the Governor on 6-20-2019
- Jun 24, 2019 · Assembly
Report vetoed by the Governor on 6-21-2019
- Jul 16, 2019 · Assembly
Referred to committee on Rules
- May 12, 2020 · Assembly
Placed on calendar 5-12-2020 pursuant to Joint Rule 82 (2)(a)
- May 12, 2020 · Assembly
Failed to pass notwithstanding the objections of the Governor pursuant to Joint Rule 82