Skip to content
Bills from the 2021–22 session

Senate Bill 894

Peer review of administrative rules, comments to proposed statements of scope, and review of proposed groundwater enforcement standards. (FE)

Stopped before the full Senate voted

The recommended passing it, but the full Senate never voted on it. To try again, a lawmaker would have to start a new bill.

  1. Introduced, passed

    Feb 1, 2022

  2. Committee, passed

    Approved

  3. Senate vote, stopped here

    Stopped here. The full Senate never voted on it.

  4. Assembly vote, not reached

  5. Governor, not reached

  6. Law, not reached

Latest entry in the official record, Mar 15, 2022: “Failed to pass pursuant to ⁠”

Read the bill

Following saves it on this device. New actions show on your Following page. You can also get updates in a feed reader.

What it would have done

Summary by the , the Legislature's nonpartisan drafting office. It's their wording, not ours.

Peer review of administrative rules This bill creates an external peer review process for administrative rules.

Under the bill, an interested party may request an external peer review of a proposed rule at any time before the proposed rule is submitted to the governor for review. An interested party is any person who will be regulated under the proposed rule or any person whose client, member, or customer will be regulated under the proposed rule. The bill also provides that the Joint Committee for Review of Administrative Rules may request an external peer review of a proposed rule or of any agency rule that has been published in the administrative code. Under the bill, if an agency receives a valid request for peer review of a proposed rule or of a rule that has been published in the code, the agency must initiate the external peer review process. A request for peer review may be made only for rules that are based on or that rely on scientific studies, scientific or technical data, scientific methods, or other similar scientific information. A request is valid if it objects to specific studies or scientific or technical data, specific methods, or specific findings, conclusions, or assumptions that the agency used in developing the rule.

Read the full summary

The bill provides that an agency that receives a valid request for peer review of a proposed rule may not continue promulgating the proposed rule until the peer review process is complete. Under the bill, the external peer review process must be completed within six months from the date on which the request for peer review was submitted, except that the deadline for completion may be extended by an additional six months if the initial six months is determined to not be feasible. In addition, the bill requires peer review questions and protocols to be approved prior to use in the peer review process by the agency and any parties requesting the peer review.

Under the bill, an agency that receives a valid request for peer review of a rule must contract with the National Academy of Sciences, Toxicology Excellence for Risk Assessment, or any similar independent scientific entity, or with a group of independent scientists of comparable stature and qualifications, to conduct an external peer review of the studies or scientific or technical data, the methods, or the findings, conclusions, or assumptions that the agency used in developing the rule.

Under the bill, a peer reviewer must have expertise in the subject matter of the rule being reviewed. The bill prohibits all of the following people from acting as peer reviewers: a party requesting the peer review, an employee of the agency or of a requesting party, or the spouse or family member of an employee of the agency or of a requesting party; an interested party or an employee of an interested party; a person who is conducting research that is funded by the agency or by a requesting party; or a person who participated in the development of any study or technical or scientific data being reviewed.

Under the bill, once the peer review process is complete, the peer review panel must prepare a final written report that provides one of two conclusions: 1) the rule is scientifically defensible; or 2) the rule is not scientifically defensible, does not comply with state or federal law, or would be scientifically defensible if the agency made certain modifications to the rule. If the peer review panel concludes that a proposed rule is scientifically defensible, the agency may continue to promulgate the proposed rule. If the peer review panel concludes that a proposed rule is not scientifically defensible, does not comply with state or federal law, or would be scientifically defensible if the agency made certain modifications to the proposed rule, the agency must modify the proposed rule as necessary, in cooperation and agreement with the party that requested the peer review, before continuing to promulgate the proposed rule. If the peer review panel concludes that a rule that has been published in the administrative code is not scientifically defensible, does not comply with state or federal law, or would be scientifically defensible if the agency made certain modifications to the code, the agency must initiate the rulemaking process to make necessary modifications to the code.

Under the bill, if the peer review panel concludes that a rule is scientifically defensible, the costs of the peer review process must be paid by the party that submitted the request for peer review. If the peer review panel concludes that a rule is not scientifically defensible, does not comply with state or federal law, or would be scientifically defensible if certain modifications were made, the agency must pay for the costs of the peer review process.

Soliciting comments on scope statements The bill also requires an agency, before submitting a statement of scope of a proposed rule to the Department of Administration and to the governor, to solicit and consider comments on the statement of scope from persons who may be regulated under the proposed rule. For rules that will be based on or rely on scientific studies, scientific or technical data, scientific methods, or other similar scientific information, the promulgating agency must incorporate comments into the statement of scope, if the comments are scientifically valid, are supported by relevant industries, and recommend changes that will ensure compliance with relevant state law and will ensure the accuracy, integrity, objectivity, or consistency of data that will be used to promulgate the rule.

Notice and review of proposed groundwater standards Under current law, the Department of Health Services develops recommendations for groundwater enforcement standards for certain substances of public health concern. The Department of Natural Resources incorporates these recommendations into its rules relating to groundwater enforcement standards.

This bill requires DHS, before submitting to DNR a recommended enforcement standard for a substance identified as a public health concern, to provide public notice of the proposed recommendation and the studies or scientific or technical data, the methodologies, and the findings, conclusions, and assumptions that DHS used in developing the recommended enforcement standard.

The bill also provides that if, before DHS submits a recommendation for a groundwater enforcement standard to DNR, an interested party objects to the recommendation based on a failure to comply with state groundwater laws or based on the accuracy, integrity, objectivity, or consistency of the data used to develop the recommendation, DHS must convene a working group to review the recommendation. The working group must consist of the interested party objecting to the recommendation, four members from statewide agriculture associations, one member from the Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection, and one member from DNR. If there is a consensus by the working group that changes are needed to ensure compliance with state groundwater laws or to ensure the accuracy, integrity, objectivity, or consistency of the data used to develop the recommendation, DHS must modify the recommendation accordingly before submitting the recommendation to DNR.

Who's behind it

2 senators are its ⁠. All 2 are Republicans.

2 more lawmakers ⁠.

See all 4 names

Authors (2)

Signed on in support (2)

What it would cost

State agencies filed a . Each opens as a PDF from the Legislature.

How lawmakers voted

There was one vote on this bill.

Senate Committee on Government Operations vote to recommend it

Passed, 3 to 2 · Feb 11, 2022

No member-by-member record exists for this vote. Committee votes and some older sessions record totals only.

Official motion: “Report passage recommended by Committee on Government Operations, Legal Review and Consumer Protection, Ayes 3, Noes 2”. Official record · This vote on its own page

What happened

  1. Mar 15, 2022

    The session ended, and the bill died with it.

  2. Feb 18, 2022

    A state agency sent in its estimate of the cost.

  3. Feb 17, 2022

    A state agency sent in its estimate of the cost.

  4. Feb 11, 2022

    The committee voted to recommend passing it, 3 to 2.

  5. Feb 8, 2022

    The committee held a public hearing.

  6. Feb 1, 2022

    Sent to the Senate Committee on Government Operations, Legal Review and Consumer Protection.

  7. Feb 1, 2022

    Introduced in the Senate.

See the official record, word for word
  1. Feb 1, 2022 · Senate

    Introduced by Senators Felzkowski and Stroebel; cosponsored by Representatives Dallman and Brooks

  2. Feb 1, 2022 · Senate

    Read first time and referred to Committee on Government Operations, Legal Review and Consumer Protection

  3. Feb 8, 2022 · Senate

    Public hearing held

  4. Feb 11, 2022 · Senate

    Executive action taken

  5. Feb 11, 2022 · Senate

    Report passage recommended by Committee on Government Operations, Legal Review and Consumer Protection, Ayes 3, Noes 2

  6. Feb 11, 2022 · Senate

    Available for scheduling

  7. Feb 17, 2022 · Senate

    Fiscal estimate received

  8. Feb 18, 2022 · Senate

    Fiscal estimate received

  9. Mar 15, 2022 · Senate

    Failed to pass pursuant to Senate Joint Resolution 1

Terms on this page

Committee

A small group of lawmakers that looks at a bill first. Most bills never leave committee.

More in the glossary

Senate Joint Resolution 1

The session's calendar. Any bill not passed by its last voting day dies.

Official term: Failed to pass pursuant to SJR 1. More in the glossary

Legislative Reference Bureau

The Legislature's nonpartisan office that drafts bills and writes the summary at the top of each one.

Official term: LRB analysis. More in the glossary

Author

A lawmaker who formally puts a bill forward. The text itself is drafted by the Legislative Reference Bureau.

Official term: Author, coauthor. More in the glossary

Signed on in support

Lawmakers who back a bill without being one of its authors, often from the other chamber.

Official term: Cosponsor. More in the glossary

Cost estimate

A state agency's estimate of what a bill would cost or save.

Official term: Fiscal estimate. More in the glossary

Roll call

A vote where each lawmaker's yes or no is recorded by name.

Official term: Roll call vote. More in the glossary

From the Wisconsin Legislature's official record, checked Sep 15, 2026. See the source

Committee

A small group of lawmakers that looks at a bill first. Most bills never leave committee.

Senate Joint Resolution 1

The session's calendar. Any bill not passed by its last voting day dies.

Official term: Failed to pass pursuant to SJR 1

Legislative Reference Bureau

The Legislature's nonpartisan office that drafts bills and writes the summary at the top of each one.

Official term: LRB analysis

Author

A lawmaker who formally puts a bill forward. The text itself is drafted by the Legislative Reference Bureau.

Official term: Author, coauthor

Signed on in support

Lawmakers who back a bill without being one of its authors, often from the other chamber.

Official term: Cosponsor

Cost estimate

A state agency's estimate of what a bill would cost or save.

Official term: Fiscal estimate

Roll call

A vote where each lawmaker's yes or no is recorded by name.

Official term: Roll call vote