Bills · 2023-2024 Regular Session
Relating to: rights reserved to a parent or guardian of a child.
Children Court — Procedure Credit Family Guardian and ward
- Introduced, completed
- Passes Assembly, completed
- Passes Senate, stopped here
- Governor signs, not reached
- Law, not reached
Unfamiliar terms? Glossary
What this bill does
Plain-language analysis by the nonpartisan Legislative Reference Bureau
This bill establishes a legal standard for state infringement on fundamental
rights of parents and guardians, explicitly establishes a number of parental and
guardian rights relating to a child's religion, medical care and records, and
education, and creates a cause of action for the violation of these rights.
The bill prohibits the state from infringing on the fundamental right of parents
to direct the upbringing, education, health care, and mental health of their children
without demonstrating that the infringement is required by a compelling
governmental interest of the highest order as applied to the child, is narrowly
tailored, and is not otherwise served by a less restrictive means.
The bill reserves all of the following rights to the parent of a child without
interference from the state or other government entity:
1. The right to determine the religion of the child.
2. The right to determine the type of school or educational setting the child
attends.
3. The right to be notified of each health care service, including vaccinations
or immunizations, offered at the child's school and the right to withhold consent or
decline any specific service, unless otherwise specified by law or court order.
4. The right to review all medical records related to the child, unless otherwise
specified by law or court order.
5. The right to determine the names and pronouns used for the child while at
school.
6. The right to review instructional materials and outlines used by the child's
school, to the extent required by federal law.
7. The right to access records regarding the education of the child that are
generated, maintained, or used by the child's school, to the extent required by federal
law.
8. The right to timely notice by the child's school of any surveys or evaluations
conducted in the child's classroom that would reveal information concerning any of
the following about the child or his or her parent or family members: political
affiliations or beliefs; mental or psychological problems; sexual behavior or attitudes;
illegal, antisocial, self-incriminating, or demeaning behavior; critical appraisals of
individuals with whom the child or parent has a close family relationship;
relationships that are legally recognized as privileged, such as those with lawyers,
physicians, and ministers; religious practices, affiliations, or beliefs; or income,
unless otherwise specified by law.
9. The right to timely notice by the child's school, through a process consistent
with school policy, of when a controversial subject will be taught or discussed in the
child's classroom. The bill defines “controversial subject” as a subject of substantial
public debate, disagreement, or disapproval and specifies that the term includes
instruction about gender identity, sexual orientation, racial identity, structural,
Sponsors
Introduced by: Allen (R) , Armstrong (R) , Behnke (R) , Binsfeld (R) , Bodden (R) , Brandtjen (R) , Brooks (R) , Callahan (R) , Dittrich (R) , Edming (R) , Goeben (R) , Green (R) , Gundrum (R) , Gustafson (R) , Magnafici (R) , Maxey (R) , Michalski (R) , Murphy (R) , Mursau (R) , Nedweski (R) , O'Connor (R) , Penterman (R) , Rettinger (R) , Sapik (R) , Schmidt (R) , Schutt (R) , Steffen (R) , Tittl (R) , VanderMeer (R) , Wichgers (R) , Wittke (R)
Votes
Assembly: Report passage recommended by Committee on Family Law, Ayes 6, Noes 3
Passed 6–3 Jan 16, 2024 official source full pageNo individual roll call was recorded for this vote. Committee votes and some older sessions record totals only.
Aye · 62
- Adam Neylon (15)
- Alex Dallman (39)
- Amanda Nedweski (32)
- Amy Binsfeld (27)
- Angie Sapik (73)
- Barbara Dittrich (99)
- Bob Donovan (61)
- Bob Wittke (63)
- Calvin Callahan (35)
- Chanz Green (74)
- Chuck Wichgers (84)
- Cindi Duchow (97)
- Clint Moses (92)
- Dave Armstrong (67)
- Dave Maxey (83)
- Dave Murphy (56)
- David Steffen (4)
- Donna Rozar (69)
- Elijah Behnke (6)
- Ellen Schutt (31)
- Gae Magnafici (28)
- Gus Gustafson (55)
- James Edming (87)
- Janel Brandtjen (22)
- Jeff Mursau (36)
- Jerry O'Connor (60)
- Jessie Rodriguez (21)
- Joel Kitchens (1)
- John Macco (88)
- John Spiros (86)
- Jon Plumer (42)
- Joy Goeben (5)
- Karen Hurd (69)
- Kevin Petersen (57)
- Mark Born (37)
- Michael Schraa (53)
- Nancy VanderMeer (70)
- Nik Rettinger (83)
- Pat Snyder (85)
- Paul Melotik (22)
- Paul Tittl (25)
- Peter Schmidt (6)
- Rick Gundrum (58)
- Rob Brooks (59)
- Rob Summerfield (68)
- Rob Swearingen (34)
- Robin Vos (33)
- Ron Tusler (3)
- Scott Allen (82)
- Scott Johnson (33)
- Scott Krug (72)
- Shae Sortwell (2)
- Shannon Zimmerman (30)
- Terry Katsma (26)
- Todd Novak (51)
- Tom Michalski (13)
- Tony Kurtz (41)
- Treig Pronschinske (29)
- Ty Bodden (59)
- Tyler August (31)
- Warren Petryk (93)
- Will Penterman (38)
Nay · 35
- Alex Joers (81)
- Christine Sinicki (20)
- Clint Anderson (45)
- Daniel Riemer (7)
- Darrin Madison (10)
- Dave Considine (81)
- Deb Andraca (23)
- Dora Drake (4)
- Evan Goyke (18)
- Francesca Hong (76)
- Greta Neubauer (66)
- Jenna Jacobson (50)
- Jill Billings (95)
- Jimmy Anderson (47)
- Jodi Emerson (91)
- Kalan Haywood (16)
- Katrina Shankland (71)
- Kristina Shelton (90)
- LaKeshia Myers (12)
- Lee Snodgrass (52)
- Lisa Subeck (79)
- Lori Palmeri (54)
- Marisabel Cabrera (9)
- Melissa Ratcliff (16)
- Mike Bare (80)
- Robyn Vining (13)
- Ryan Clancy (19)
- Samba Baldeh (48)
- Shelia Stubbs (78)
- Steve Doyle (94)
- Sue Conley (44)
- Supreme Moore Omokunde (17)
- Sylvia Ortiz-Velez (8)
- Tip McGuire (64)
- Tod Ohnstad (65)
Not voting · 2
- Loren Oldenburg (96)
- Travis Tranel (49)
Senate: Public hearing requirement waived by committee on Senate Organization, pursuant to Senate Rule 18 (1m), Ayes 3, Noes 2
Passed 3–2 Feb 9, 2024 official source full pageNo individual roll call was recorded for this vote. Committee votes and some older sessions record totals only.
Senate: Senate Substitute Amendment 1 rejected, Ayes 22, Noes 10
Passed 22–10 Feb 13, 2024 official source full pageNo individual roll call was recorded for this vote. Committee votes and some older sessions record totals only.
Aye · 22
- André Jacque (1)
- Chris Kapenga (33)
- Cory Tomczyk (29)
- Dan Feyen (20)
- Dan Knodl (24)
- Devin LeMahieu (9)
- Duey Stroebel (20)
- Eric Wimberger (2)
- Howard Marklein (17)
- Jesse James (23)
- Joan Ballweg (14)
- John Jagler (13)
- Julian Bradley (28)
- Mary Felzkowski (12)
- Patrick Testin (24)
- Rachael Cabral-Guevara (19)
- Rob Cowles (2)
- Rob Hutton (5)
- Rob Stafsholt (10)
- Romaine Quinn (25)
- Steve Nass (11)
- Van Wanggaard (21)
Nay · 10
- Bob Wirch (22)
- Brad Pfaff (32)
- Chris Larson (7)
- Dianne Hesselbein (27)
- Jeff Smith (31)
- Kelda Roys (26)
- LaTonya Johnson (6)
- Mark Spreitzer (15)
- Melissa Agard (16)
- Tim Carpenter (3)
Full history
- Oct 18, 2023 · Assembly
Introduced by Representatives Wittke, Gundrum, Maxey, Nedweski, Schmidt, Binsfeld, Rettinger, Allen, Magnafici, Steffen, Brooks, Armstrong, Callahan, O'Connor, Goeben, Bodden, Sapik, Tittl, Michalski, Schutt, Penterman, Dittrich, Murphy, Green, Behnke, Mursau, Brandtjen, Wichgers, Gustafson, VanderMeer and Edming; cosponsored by Senators Wanggaard, Quinn, Marklein and Nass
- Oct 18, 2023 · Assembly
Read first time and referred to Committee on Family Law
- Nov 8, 2023 · Assembly
Public hearing held
- Jan 11, 2024 · Assembly
Executive action taken
- Jan 16, 2024 · Assembly
Report passage recommended by Committee on Family Law, Ayes 6, Noes 3
- Jan 16, 2024 · Assembly
Referred to committee on Rules
- Jan 16, 2024 · Assembly
Placed on calendar 1-18-2024 by Committee on Rules
- Jan 17, 2024 · Assembly
Representative Macco added as a coauthor
- Jan 18, 2024 · Assembly
Rules suspended
- Jan 18, 2024 · Assembly
Read a third time and passed, Ayes 62, Noes 35
- Jan 18, 2024 · Assembly
Ordered immediately messaged
- Jan 18, 2024 · Senate
Received from Assembly
- Jan 18, 2024 · Assembly
Read a second time
- Jan 18, 2024 · Assembly
Ordered to a third reading
- Jan 19, 2024 · Senate
Read first time and referred to committee on Education
- Feb 5, 2024 · Senate
Withdrawn from committee on Education and rereferred to committee on Senate Organization pursuant to Senate Rule 46(2)(c)
- Feb 5, 2024 · Senate
Available for scheduling
- Feb 9, 2024 · Senate
Public hearing requirement waived by committee on Senate Organization, pursuant to Senate Rule 18 (1m), Ayes 3, Noes 2
- Feb 9, 2024 · Senate
Placed on calendar 2-13-2024 pursuant to Senate Rule 18(1)
- Feb 13, 2024 · Senate
Senate Substitute Amendment 1 offered by Senators Larson, Agard, Carpenter, Hesselbein, L. Johnson, Pfaff, Roys, Smith, Spreitzer and Wirch
- Feb 13, 2024 · Senate
Read a second time
- Feb 13, 2024 · Senate
Senate Substitute Amendment 1 rejected, Ayes 22, Noes 10
- Feb 13, 2024 · Senate
Ordered to a third reading
- Feb 13, 2024 · Senate
Rules suspended to give bill its third reading
- Feb 13, 2024 · Senate
Read a third time and concurred in, Ayes 22, Noes 10
- Feb 13, 2024 · Senate
Ordered immediately messaged
- Feb 13, 2024 · Assembly
Received from Senate concurred in
- Feb 15, 2024 · Assembly
Report correctly enrolled on 2-15-2024
- Mar 26, 2024 · Assembly
Presented to the Governor on 3-26-2024
- Mar 29, 2024 · Assembly
Report vetoed by the Governor on 3-29-2024
- May 14, 2024 · Assembly
Placed on calendar 5-14-2024 pursuant to Joint Rule 82 (2)(a)
- May 15, 2024 · Assembly
Failed to pass notwithstanding the objections of the Governor pursuant to Joint Rule 82