Bills · 2023-2024 Regular Session
Relating to: free speech and academic freedom at University of Wisconsin System institutions and technical colleges, due process in disciplinary proceedings at University of Wisconsin System institutions and technical colleges, Wisconsin grant funding allocation, and causes of action against the Board of Regents of the University of Wisconsin System and technical college district boards. (FE)
Court — Procedure Freedom of speech and press Higher educational aids board Technical college University of wisconsin University of wisconsin — Student life
- Introduced, stopped here
- Passes Assembly, not reached
- Passes Senate, not reached
- Governor signs, not reached
- Law, not reached
Unfamiliar terms? Glossary
What this bill does
Plain-language analysis by the nonpartisan Legislative Reference Bureau
This bill establishes certain standards related to free speech and academic
freedom at University of Wisconsin System institutions and technical colleges. For
violation of these standards, the Board of Regents of the UW System or technical
college district board may be subject to a civil cause of action and must provide
certain public notice of the violation.
The bill also establishes certain due process standards in disciplinary
proceedings at UW System institutions and technical colleges. For violation of these
standards, a UW institution or technical college may become ineligible for Wisconsin
grant funding allocation.
free speech and academic freedom
First Amendment protections
Under the bill, a UW institution or technical college may not do any of the
following: 1) restrict speech protected under the First Amendment, if the speaker's
conduct is not unlawful and does not materially and substantially disrupt the
functioning of the UW institution or technical college; 2) maintain and enforce time,
place, and manner restrictions on expressive activities on the publicly accessible,
open outdoor areas of its campus and indoor areas that have been designated as
public forums, except classrooms while they are in use for instructional purposes,
unless those restrictions meet specified requirements; 3) designate any area of a
campus a “free speech zone” or otherwise create policies restricting noncommercial
expressive activities to a particular area of a campus; 4) subject to an exception,
require a permit as a condition of being allowed to engage in expressive activities
protected under the bill; 5) charge security fees, as part of a permit application, based
on the content of expression or anticipated reaction; or 6) sanction individuals or
groups for discriminatory harassment unless the speech targets its victim on the
basis of a protected class under law, and is so severe, pervasive, and objectively
offensive that it effectively bars a student from receiving equal access to educational
opportunities or benefits. Under the bill, if a permit is required, the permitting
process and any security fee must be content and viewpoint neutral.
The bill also specifies that all of an institution's or technical college's indoor
areas that have been designated as public forums and publicly accessible outdoor
areas, except classrooms while they are in use for instructional purposes, are
governed by rules applicable to traditional public forums. The bill specifies that its
provisions do not 1) enable individuals to engage in conduct that intentionally,
materially, and substantially disrupts another's expressive activity in a campus
space reserved for that activity; or 2) limit the right of student expression at campus
locations not specified in the bill.
The bill requires an institution or technical college to do all of the following: 1)
conduct a survey biennially of students and employees on First Amendment rights,
academic freedom, perceived political or other bias at the institution or technical
What it would cost
Fiscal estimates filed by state agencies, as official PDFs
Sponsors
Votes
Assembly: Report Assembly Amendment 1 adoption recommended by Committee on Colleges and Universities, Ayes 14, Noes 0
Passed 14–0 Nov 2, 2023 official source full pageNo individual roll call was recorded for this vote. Committee votes and some older sessions record totals only.
Assembly: Report Assembly Amendment 2 adoption recommended by Committee on Colleges and Universities, Ayes 10, Noes 4
Passed 10–4 Nov 2, 2023 official source full pageNo individual roll call was recorded for this vote. Committee votes and some older sessions record totals only.
Assembly: Report passage as amended recommended by Committee on Colleges and Universities, Ayes 10, Noes 4
Passed 10–4 Nov 2, 2023 official source full pageNo individual roll call was recorded for this vote. Committee votes and some older sessions record totals only.
Aye · 62
- Adam Neylon (15)
- Alex Dallman (39)
- Amanda Nedweski (32)
- Amy Binsfeld (27)
- Angie Sapik (73)
- Barbara Dittrich (99)
- Bob Donovan (61)
- Bob Wittke (63)
- Calvin Callahan (35)
- Chanz Green (74)
- Chuck Wichgers (84)
- Cindi Duchow (97)
- Clint Moses (92)
- Dave Armstrong (67)
- Dave Maxey (83)
- Dave Murphy (56)
- David Steffen (4)
- Donna Rozar (69)
- Elijah Behnke (6)
- Ellen Schutt (31)
- Gae Magnafici (28)
- Gus Gustafson (55)
- James Edming (87)
- Janel Brandtjen (22)
- Jeff Mursau (36)
- Jerry O'Connor (60)
- Jessie Rodriguez (21)
- Joel Kitchens (1)
- John Macco (88)
- John Spiros (86)
- Jon Plumer (42)
- Joy Goeben (5)
- Karen Hurd (69)
- Kevin Petersen (57)
- Loren Oldenburg (96)
- Mark Born (37)
- Nancy VanderMeer (70)
- Nik Rettinger (83)
- Pat Snyder (85)
- Paul Melotik (22)
- Paul Tittl (25)
- Peter Schmidt (6)
- Rick Gundrum (58)
- Rob Brooks (59)
- Rob Summerfield (68)
- Rob Swearingen (34)
- Robin Vos (33)
- Ron Tusler (3)
- Scott Allen (82)
- Scott Johnson (33)
- Scott Krug (72)
- Shae Sortwell (2)
- Shannon Zimmerman (30)
- Terry Katsma (26)
- Tom Michalski (13)
- Tony Kurtz (41)
- Travis Tranel (49)
- Treig Pronschinske (29)
- Ty Bodden (59)
- Tyler August (31)
- Warren Petryk (93)
- Will Penterman (38)
Nay · 36
- Alex Joers (81)
- Christine Sinicki (20)
- Clint Anderson (45)
- Daniel Riemer (7)
- Darrin Madison (10)
- Dave Considine (81)
- Deb Andraca (23)
- Dora Drake (4)
- Evan Goyke (18)
- Francesca Hong (76)
- Greta Neubauer (66)
- Jenna Jacobson (50)
- Jill Billings (95)
- Jimmy Anderson (47)
- Jodi Emerson (91)
- Kalan Haywood (16)
- Katrina Shankland (71)
- Kristina Shelton (90)
- LaKeshia Myers (12)
- Lee Snodgrass (52)
- Lisa Subeck (79)
- Lori Palmeri (54)
- Marisabel Cabrera (9)
- Melissa Ratcliff (16)
- Mike Bare (80)
- Robyn Vining (13)
- Ryan Clancy (19)
- Samba Baldeh (48)
- Shelia Stubbs (78)
- Steve Doyle (94)
- Sue Conley (44)
- Supreme Moore Omokunde (17)
- Sylvia Ortiz-Velez (8)
- Tip McGuire (64)
- Tod Ohnstad (65)
- Todd Novak (51)
Not voting · 1
- Michael Schraa (53)
Full history
- Oct 23, 2023 · Assembly
Introduced by Representatives Nedweski, Murphy, Allen, Behnke, Brandtjen, Dittrich, Edming, Goeben, Gundrum, Maxey, Moses, O'Connor, Penterman, Rettinger, Schraa and Tusler; cosponsored by Senators Cabral-Guevara and Tomczyk
- Oct 23, 2023 · Assembly
Read first time and referred to Committee on Colleges and Universities
- Oct 26, 2023 · Assembly
Public hearing held
- Oct 31, 2023 · Assembly
Assembly Amendment 1 offered by Representative Nedweski
- Nov 1, 2023 · Assembly
Assembly Amendment 2 offered by Representative Nedweski
- Nov 1, 2023 · Assembly
Fiscal estimate received
- Nov 2, 2023 · Assembly
Referred to committee on Rules
- Nov 2, 2023 · Assembly
Placed on calendar 11-7-2023 by Committee on Rules
- Nov 2, 2023 · Assembly
Executive action taken
- Nov 2, 2023 · Assembly
Report Assembly Amendment 1 adoption recommended by Committee on Colleges and Universities, Ayes 14, Noes 0
- Nov 2, 2023 · Assembly
Report Assembly Amendment 2 adoption recommended by Committee on Colleges and Universities, Ayes 10, Noes 4
- Nov 2, 2023 · Assembly
Report passage as amended recommended by Committee on Colleges and Universities, Ayes 10, Noes 4
- Nov 6, 2023 · Assembly
Representative Gustafson added as a coauthor
- Nov 7, 2023 · Assembly
Read a second time
- Nov 7, 2023 · Assembly
Assembly Amendment 1 adopted
- Nov 7, 2023 · Assembly
Assembly Amendment 2 adopted
- Nov 7, 2023 · Assembly
Ordered to a third reading
- Nov 7, 2023 · Assembly
Rules suspended
- Nov 7, 2023 · Assembly
Read a third time and passed, Ayes 62, Noes 36
- Nov 7, 2023 · Assembly
Ordered immediately messaged
- Nov 8, 2023 · Senate
Received from Assembly
- Nov 9, 2023 · Senate
Read first time and referred to committee on Universities and Revenue
- Dec 5, 2023 · Senate
Public hearing held
- Apr 15, 2024 · Senate
Failed to concur in pursuant to Senate Joint Resolution 1