Bills · 2023-2024 Regular Session
Relating to: prohibiting discrimination in organ transplantation and donation on the basis of an individual's vaccination status.
Discrimination Transplant Vaccination
- Introduced, completed
- Passes Senate, completed
- Passes Assembly, stopped here
- Governor signs, not reached
- Law, not reached
Unfamiliar terms? Glossary
What this bill does
Plain-language analysis by the nonpartisan Legislative Reference Bureau
Current law prohibits hospitals and transplant hospitals from taking certain
actions related to organ transplantation solely on the basis of an individual's
disability. This bill expands these prohibitions to actions taken solely on the basis
of an individual's vaccination status. Under the bill, “vaccination status” means the
status of an individual having received or not received, for reasons of health, religion,
or personal conviction, one or more doses of a vaccine that 1) is authorized for
emergency use by the federal Food and Drug Administration, 2) operates through the
transfer of genetic material into humans, 3) has an annual dosing schedule, or 4) is
for the prevention of a disease against which the individual is protected, as shown
by an antibody titer. Specifically, the bill prohibits hospitals and transplant
hospitals from taking any of the following actions solely on the basis of an
individual's vaccination status: 1) considering the individual ineligible to receive an
anatomical gift; 2) denying the individual any services related to organ
transplantation; 3) refusing to refer the individual to a transplant hospital or an
organ transplant specialist to be evaluated for or receive an anatomical gift; 4)
refusing to place the individual on an organ transplant waiting list; and 5) placing
the individual on an organ transplant waiting list at a lower priority position than
the position at which the individual would have been placed if not for the individual's
vaccination status. The bill also prohibits hospitals and transplant hospitals from
removing an individual from an organ transplant waiting list solely on the basis of
the individual's vaccination status or disability. In addition, the bill prohibits the
denial of insurance coverage for any procedure associated with being evaluated for
or receiving an anatomical gift solely on the basis of an individual's vaccination
status. The bill allows an individual to bring an action in circuit court for taking any
of these actions in violation of the bill. Under the bill, the court must hold a hearing
within 30 days of the filing of the action.
In addition, the bill prohibits any person from discriminating against an
individual in any matter relating to donating or receiving an anatomical gift on the
basis of the individual's vaccination status.
Sponsors
Votes
Senate: Report passage recommended by Committee on Health, Ayes 4, Noes 2
Passed 4–2 Feb 13, 2024 official source full pageNo individual roll call was recorded for this vote. Committee votes and some older sessions record totals only.
Aye · 21
- André Jacque (1)
- Chris Kapenga (33)
- Cory Tomczyk (29)
- Dan Feyen (20)
- Dan Knodl (24)
- Devin LeMahieu (9)
- Duey Stroebel (20)
- Eric Wimberger (2)
- Howard Marklein (17)
- Jesse James (23)
- Joan Ballweg (14)
- John Jagler (13)
- Julian Bradley (28)
- Mary Felzkowski (12)
- Patrick Testin (24)
- Rachael Cabral-Guevara (19)
- Rob Hutton (5)
- Rob Stafsholt (10)
- Romaine Quinn (25)
- Steve Nass (11)
- Van Wanggaard (21)
Nay · 11
- Bob Wirch (22)
- Brad Pfaff (32)
- Chris Larson (7)
- Dianne Hesselbein (27)
- Jeff Smith (31)
- Kelda Roys (26)
- LaTonya Johnson (6)
- Mark Spreitzer (15)
- Melissa Agard (16)
- Rob Cowles (2)
- Tim Carpenter (3)
Aye · 62
- Adam Neylon (15)
- Alex Dallman (39)
- Amanda Nedweski (32)
- Amy Binsfeld (27)
- Barbara Dittrich (99)
- Bob Donovan (61)
- Bob Wittke (63)
- Calvin Callahan (35)
- Chanz Green (74)
- Chuck Wichgers (84)
- Cindi Duchow (97)
- Clint Moses (92)
- Dave Armstrong (67)
- Dave Maxey (83)
- Dave Murphy (56)
- David Steffen (4)
- Donna Rozar (69)
- Elijah Behnke (6)
- Ellen Schutt (31)
- Gae Magnafici (28)
- Gus Gustafson (55)
- James Edming (87)
- Janel Brandtjen (22)
- Jeff Mursau (36)
- Jerry O'Connor (60)
- Jessie Rodriguez (21)
- Joel Kitchens (1)
- John Macco (88)
- John Spiros (86)
- Jon Plumer (42)
- Joy Goeben (5)
- Karen Hurd (69)
- Kevin Petersen (57)
- Loren Oldenburg (96)
- Mark Born (37)
- Michael Schraa (53)
- Nancy VanderMeer (70)
- Nik Rettinger (83)
- Pat Snyder (85)
- Paul Melotik (22)
- Paul Tittl (25)
- Peter Schmidt (6)
- Rick Gundrum (58)
- Rob Brooks (59)
- Rob Summerfield (68)
- Rob Swearingen (34)
- Robin Vos (33)
- Ron Tusler (3)
- Scott Allen (82)
- Scott Johnson (33)
- Scott Krug (72)
- Shae Sortwell (2)
- Terry Katsma (26)
- Todd Novak (51)
- Tom Michalski (13)
- Tony Kurtz (41)
- Travis Tranel (49)
- Treig Pronschinske (29)
- Ty Bodden (59)
- Tyler August (31)
- Warren Petryk (93)
- Will Penterman (38)
Nay · 35
- Alex Joers (81)
- Christine Sinicki (20)
- Clint Anderson (45)
- Daniel Riemer (7)
- Darrin Madison (10)
- Dave Considine (81)
- Deb Andraca (23)
- Dora Drake (4)
- Evan Goyke (18)
- Francesca Hong (76)
- Greta Neubauer (66)
- Jenna Jacobson (50)
- Jill Billings (95)
- Jimmy Anderson (47)
- Jodi Emerson (91)
- Kalan Haywood (16)
- Katrina Shankland (71)
- Kristina Shelton (90)
- LaKeshia Myers (12)
- Lee Snodgrass (52)
- Lisa Subeck (79)
- Lori Palmeri (54)
- Marisabel Cabrera (9)
- Melissa Ratcliff (16)
- Mike Bare (80)
- Robyn Vining (13)
- Ryan Clancy (19)
- Samba Baldeh (48)
- Shelia Stubbs (78)
- Steve Doyle (94)
- Sue Conley (44)
- Supreme Moore Omokunde (17)
- Sylvia Ortiz-Velez (8)
- Tip McGuire (64)
- Tod Ohnstad (65)
Not voting · 2
- Angie Sapik (73)
- Shannon Zimmerman (30)
Aye · 62
- Adam Neylon (15)
- Alex Dallman (39)
- Amanda Nedweski (32)
- Amy Binsfeld (27)
- Barbara Dittrich (99)
- Bob Donovan (61)
- Bob Wittke (63)
- Calvin Callahan (35)
- Chanz Green (74)
- Chuck Wichgers (84)
- Cindi Duchow (97)
- Clint Moses (92)
- Dave Armstrong (67)
- Dave Maxey (83)
- Dave Murphy (56)
- David Steffen (4)
- Donna Rozar (69)
- Elijah Behnke (6)
- Ellen Schutt (31)
- Gae Magnafici (28)
- Gus Gustafson (55)
- James Edming (87)
- Janel Brandtjen (22)
- Jeff Mursau (36)
- Jerry O'Connor (60)
- Jessie Rodriguez (21)
- Joel Kitchens (1)
- John Macco (88)
- John Spiros (86)
- Jon Plumer (42)
- Joy Goeben (5)
- Karen Hurd (69)
- Kevin Petersen (57)
- Loren Oldenburg (96)
- Mark Born (37)
- Michael Schraa (53)
- Nancy VanderMeer (70)
- Nik Rettinger (83)
- Pat Snyder (85)
- Paul Melotik (22)
- Paul Tittl (25)
- Peter Schmidt (6)
- Rick Gundrum (58)
- Rob Brooks (59)
- Rob Summerfield (68)
- Rob Swearingen (34)
- Robin Vos (33)
- Ron Tusler (3)
- Scott Allen (82)
- Scott Johnson (33)
- Scott Krug (72)
- Shae Sortwell (2)
- Terry Katsma (26)
- Todd Novak (51)
- Tom Michalski (13)
- Tony Kurtz (41)
- Travis Tranel (49)
- Treig Pronschinske (29)
- Ty Bodden (59)
- Tyler August (31)
- Warren Petryk (93)
- Will Penterman (38)
Nay · 35
- Alex Joers (81)
- Christine Sinicki (20)
- Clint Anderson (45)
- Daniel Riemer (7)
- Darrin Madison (10)
- Dave Considine (81)
- Deb Andraca (23)
- Dora Drake (4)
- Evan Goyke (18)
- Francesca Hong (76)
- Greta Neubauer (66)
- Jenna Jacobson (50)
- Jill Billings (95)
- Jimmy Anderson (47)
- Jodi Emerson (91)
- Kalan Haywood (16)
- Katrina Shankland (71)
- Kristina Shelton (90)
- LaKeshia Myers (12)
- Lee Snodgrass (52)
- Lisa Subeck (79)
- Lori Palmeri (54)
- Marisabel Cabrera (9)
- Melissa Ratcliff (16)
- Mike Bare (80)
- Robyn Vining (13)
- Ryan Clancy (19)
- Samba Baldeh (48)
- Shelia Stubbs (78)
- Steve Doyle (94)
- Sue Conley (44)
- Supreme Moore Omokunde (17)
- Sylvia Ortiz-Velez (8)
- Tip McGuire (64)
- Tod Ohnstad (65)
Not voting · 2
- Angie Sapik (73)
- Shannon Zimmerman (30)
Full history
- Jan 19, 2024 · Senate
Introduced by Senators Cabral-Guevara, Felzkowski and Nass; cosponsored by Representatives Goeben, Allen, Behnke, Brandtjen, Dittrich, Edming, Maxey, Murphy, Rettinger, Sapik, Schutt and Wichgers
- Jan 19, 2024 · Senate
Read first time and referred to Committee on Health
- Feb 6, 2024 · Senate
Public hearing held
- Feb 8, 2024 · Senate
Senator Testin added as a coauthor
- Feb 9, 2024 · Senate
Executive action taken
- Feb 13, 2024 · Senate
Report passage recommended by Committee on Health, Ayes 4, Noes 2
- Feb 13, 2024 · Senate
Available for scheduling
- Feb 19, 2024 · Senate
Placed on calendar 2-20-2024 pursuant to Senate Rule 18(1)
- Feb 20, 2024 · Senate
Rules suspended to give bill its third reading
- Feb 20, 2024 · Senate
Read a third time and passed, Ayes 21, Noes 11
- Feb 20, 2024 · Senate
Ordered immediately messaged
- Feb 20, 2024 · Assembly
Received from Senate
- Feb 20, 2024 · Assembly
Read first time and referred to committee on Rules
- Feb 20, 2024 · Assembly
Made a special order of business at 10:43 AM on 2-22-2024 pursuant to Assembly Resolution 28
- Feb 20, 2024 · Senate
Read a second time
- Feb 20, 2024 · Senate
Ordered to a third reading
- Feb 22, 2024 · Assembly
Read a second time
- Feb 22, 2024 · Assembly
Assembly Substitute Amendment 1 offered by Representative J. Anderson
- Feb 22, 2024 · Assembly
Point of order that Assembly Substitute Amendment 1 not germane under Assembly Rule 54 (3)(f) well taken
- Feb 22, 2024 · Assembly
Decision of the Chair appealed
- Feb 22, 2024 · Assembly
Decision of the Chair upheld, Ayes 62, Noes 35
- Feb 22, 2024 · Assembly
Assembly Substitute Amendment 2 offered by Representative McGuire
- Feb 22, 2024 · Assembly
Point of order that Assembly Substitute Amendment 2 not germane under Assembly Rule 54 (3)(f) well taken
- Feb 22, 2024 · Assembly
Decision of the Chair appealed
- Feb 22, 2024 · Assembly
Decision of the Chair upheld, Ayes 62, Noes 35
- Feb 22, 2024 · Assembly
Ordered to a third reading
- Feb 22, 2024 · Assembly
Rules suspended
- Feb 22, 2024 · Assembly
Read a third time and concurred in
- Feb 22, 2024 · Assembly
Ordered immediately messaged
- Feb 22, 2024 · Senate
Received from Assembly concurred in
- Feb 27, 2024 · Senate
Report correctly enrolled
- Mar 26, 2024 · Senate
Presented to the Governor on 3-26-2024
- Mar 29, 2024 · Senate
Report vetoed by the Governor on 3-29-2024
- May 13, 2024 · Senate
Placed on calendar 5-14-2024 pursuant to Joint Rule 82 (2)(a)
- May 14, 2024 · Senate
Failed to pass notwithstanding the objections of the Governor pursuant to Joint Rule 82