Skip to content
Madison Common Council

John W. Duncan

Former member of the Madison Common Council. A nonpartisan office.

Coverage starts in 2025. History is still being collected. 9 listed meetings await collection or refresh. Individual votes appear only when recorded by the clerk; voice votes do not identify each member's position. Tallies count both No and Nay as votes against; individual rows keep the clerk's wording.

Their record

Do they show up?

Present at 23 of 26 meetings where the roll was called (88%).

As the clerk recorded it: Present 36, Excused 3.

How often do they vote no?

Voted no 6 times in 25 recorded votes, and was never the only no vote.

How often are they on the losing side?

3 of their 25 yes-or-no votes on items with a recorded outcome (12%) went the other way from the council's result.

What have they moved?

The council's record names John W. Duncan as the mover of 4 items.

What the words on this page mean
Aye
voted yes
Present
attended but voted neither yes nor no
Excused
absent with notice

Each row keeps the clerk's own words, and the linked pages have the full record; these are plain readings of them.

Votes where someone voted no: 23

John W. Duncan's vote and the council's tally on every item with at least one no. The vote is on the action named, which may be a referral or postponement rather than final passage.

  • 92386: SUBSTITUTE: Amending Subsections 5.19(6), (7)(i) and (8) and amending Subsection 5.20(9)(f) of the Madison General Ordinances to add public reporting requirements for the Office of the Independent Monitor and Police Civilian Oversight Board.

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Re-refer. 16 Aye, 4 No. Meeting record for Apr 21, 2026

  • 91958: Appeal of Madison Landmarks Commission denying a Certificate of Appropriateness for 1123 Jenifer Street - Exterior Alteration in the Third Lake Ridge Historic District - Roof Replacement (District 6)

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Deny. 17 Aye, 3 No. Meeting record for Mar 10, 2026

  • 90552: SUBSTITUTE: Amending Sections of Chapter 28 of the Madison General Ordinances related to Housing and Auto-Oriented Uses in the Transit Oriented Development Overlay District.

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt with Conditions and Close the Public Hearing. 17 Aye, 3 No. Meeting record for Dec 9, 2025

  • 90552: SUBSTITUTE: Amending Sections of Chapter 28 of the Madison General Ordinances related to Housing and Auto-Oriented Uses in the Transit Oriented Development Overlay District.

    Their vote: No. The council's action: Adopt the Following Amendment(s). 1 Aye, 18 No. Meeting record for Dec 9, 2025

  • 90845: Approving Plans, Specifications, And Schedule Of Assessments For Pontiac Trail, Boston Court, Rosewood Circle, and Nokomis Circle Assessment District - 2025. (District 10)

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt and Close the Public Hearing. 19 Aye, 1 No. Meeting record for Dec 9, 2025

  • 90169: SUBSTITUTE: Creating Section 23.202 of the Madison General Ordinances related to Age Restrictions on Hemp-Derived THC Products.

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt Substitute. 13 Aye, 5 No. Meeting record for Nov 25, 2025

  • 90423: Creating Section 23.65 of the Madison General Ordinances to regulate the sale of pets in retail pet stores.

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt Alternate. 9 Aye, 9 No. Meeting record for Nov 25, 2025

  • 90169: SUBSTITUTE: Creating Section 23.202 of the Madison General Ordinances related to Age Restrictions on Hemp-Derived THC Products.

    Their vote: No. The council's action: Adopt Alternate. 6 Aye, 12 No. Meeting record for Nov 25, 2025

  • Untitled item

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Call the Question. 17 Aye, 3 No. Meeting record for Nov 11, 2025

  • 90249: 2026 Executive Operating Budget

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt. 18 Aye, 2 No. Meeting record for Nov 11, 2025

Show 13 more split votes
  • 90249: 2026 Executive Operating Budget

    Their vote: No. The council's action: Adopt. 3 Aye, 17 No. Meeting record for Nov 11, 2025

  • 89347: Authorizing execution of a sole source $150,000 contract with Downtown Madison Inc. for the preparation of a Downtown Economic Investment Strategy (District 2, District 4, District 6, District 8, and District 13).

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Reconsider. 16 Aye, 4 No. Meeting record for Oct 7, 2025

  • 89779: SUBSTITUTE: Extending the contract between the City of Madison and MACH Onehealth, Inc. dba Madison Street Medicine to provide those services and extend currently allocated funding through April 2026, at an additional cost of $0 dollars from the City of Madison, and authorizes the use of up to $100,000 of additional funds from Dane County to pay for those services

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt Substitute. 10 Aye, 9 No. Meeting record for Sep 16, 2025

  • 88846: AMENDED: Creating Subdivision 8.35(3)(f) of the Madison General Ordinances to allow for construction and change in the legal status of certain lands associated with the Madison LakeWay Project.

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt As Amended. 17 Aye, 3 No. Meeting record for Jul 15, 2025

  • 88846: AMENDED: Creating Subdivision 8.35(3)(f) of the Madison General Ordinances to allow for construction and change in the legal status of certain lands associated with the Madison LakeWay Project.

    Their vote: No. The council's action: Refer. 4 Aye, 16 No. Meeting record for Jul 15, 2025

  • 88846: AMENDED: Creating Subdivision 8.35(3)(f) of the Madison General Ordinances to allow for construction and change in the legal status of certain lands associated with the Madison LakeWay Project.

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt the Following Amendment(s). 17 Aye, 3 No. Meeting record for Jul 15, 2025

  • 83669: SECOND SUBSTITUTE: Amending Section 38.05(9)(f) of the Madison General Ordinances related to geographic limitations on Class A and Class B license applications considered by the Common Council after adoption of this ordinance for purposes of regulating density of such alcohol beverage licenses.

    Their vote: No. The council's action: Adopt. 4 Aye, 16 No. Meeting record for Jul 1, 2025

  • 85327: ALTERNATE: Amending Section 5.20(3)(a)3. of the Madison General Ordinances to modify the nomination process to the Police Civilian Oversight Board to align with current procedures for seeking applications.

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Re-refer. 15 Aye, 4 No. Meeting record for Jul 1, 2025

  • 83669: SECOND SUBSTITUTE: Amending Section 38.05(9)(f) of the Madison General Ordinances related to geographic limitations on Class A and Class B license applications considered by the Common Council after adoption of this ordinance for purposes of regulating density of such alcohol beverage licenses.

    Their vote: No. The council's action: Adopt the Following Amendment(s). 10 Aye, 10 No. Meeting record for Jul 1, 2025

  • 83477: SUBSTITUTE: Creating Section 28.022-00672 of the Madison General Ordinances to change the zoning of property located at 6610-6706 Old Sauk Road from SR-C1 (Suburban Residential-Consistent 1) District and SR-C3 (Suburban Residential-Consistent 3) District to TR-U2 (Traditional Residential-Urban 2) District. (District 19)

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt. 16 Aye, 4 No. Meeting record for Jun 17, 2025

  • 86169: Authorizing the eventual forgiveness of $1,613,365 of debt held by Madison Ice Inc. for the Madison Ice Arena (725 Forward Drive) and Hartmeyer Ice Arena (1810 and 1834 Commercial Avenue), authorizing the termination of existing land contracts for both ice arenas with Madison Ice Hartmeyer, LLC and Madison Ice MIA, LLC (Madison Ice, Inc.), authorizing the fee simple sale of Hartmeyer Ice Arena to East Madison Ice Collective and the fee simple sale of Madison Ice Arena to Madison Ice, Inc. for $1, authorizing a fundraising requirement of approximately $3 million by East Madison Ice Collective for capital improvements to Hartmeyer Ice Arena, and authorizing additional terms related to the renegotiation of the City’s relationship to the ice arenas (District 12 and District 19).

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt with the Recommendation(s). 16 Aye, 1 No. Meeting record for Jan 14, 2025

  • 85413: Hearing re: Ethics Board Complaint filed by Emily Samson against Shadayra Kilfoy-Flores

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt. 9 Aye, 4 No. Meeting record for Jan 14, 2025

  • 86169: Authorizing the eventual forgiveness of $1,613,365 of debt held by Madison Ice Inc. for the Madison Ice Arena (725 Forward Drive) and Hartmeyer Ice Arena (1810 and 1834 Commercial Avenue), authorizing the termination of existing land contracts for both ice arenas with Madison Ice Hartmeyer, LLC and Madison Ice MIA, LLC (Madison Ice, Inc.), authorizing the fee simple sale of Hartmeyer Ice Arena to East Madison Ice Collective and the fee simple sale of Madison Ice Arena to Madison Ice, Inc. for $1, authorizing a fundraising requirement of approximately $3 million by East Madison Ice Collective for capital improvements to Hartmeyer Ice Arena, and authorizing additional terms related to the renegotiation of the City’s relationship to the ice arenas (District 12 and District 19).

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Call the Question. 15 Aye, 4 No. Meeting record for Jan 14, 2025

Items they moved: 4

Items the council's record names John W. Duncan as the mover of, newest first.

Recent votes

All 25 recorded votes, newest first. The complete record is in the city's own system, and every vote we've collected is listed page by page.

Start at a year: 20262025

  • 92386: SUBSTITUTE: Amending Subsections 5.19(6), (7)(i) and (8) and amending Subsection 5.20(9)(f) of the Madison General Ordinances to add public reporting requirements for the Office of the Independent Monitor and Police Civilian Oversight Board.

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Re-refer. Meeting record for Apr 21, 2026

  • 91958: Appeal of Madison Landmarks Commission denying a Certificate of Appropriateness for 1123 Jenifer Street - Exterior Alteration in the Third Lake Ridge Historic District - Roof Replacement (District 6)

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Deny. Meeting record for Mar 10, 2026

  • 90552: SUBSTITUTE: Amending Sections of Chapter 28 of the Madison General Ordinances related to Housing and Auto-Oriented Uses in the Transit Oriented Development Overlay District.

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt with Conditions and Close the Public Hearing. Meeting record for Dec 9, 2025

  • 90557: SUBSTITUTE: Amending Sections within Chapters 16 and 28 of the Madison General Ordinances to create “Cottage Courts.”

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt with Conditions and Close the Public Hearing. Meeting record for Dec 9, 2025

  • 90552: SUBSTITUTE: Amending Sections of Chapter 28 of the Madison General Ordinances related to Housing and Auto-Oriented Uses in the Transit Oriented Development Overlay District.

    Their vote: No. The council's action: Adopt the Following Amendment(s). Meeting record for Dec 9, 2025

  • 90845: Approving Plans, Specifications, And Schedule Of Assessments For Pontiac Trail, Boston Court, Rosewood Circle, and Nokomis Circle Assessment District - 2025. (District 10)

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt and Close the Public Hearing. Meeting record for Dec 9, 2025

  • 90169: SUBSTITUTE: Creating Section 23.202 of the Madison General Ordinances related to Age Restrictions on Hemp-Derived THC Products.

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt Substitute. Meeting record for Nov 25, 2025

  • 90423: Creating Section 23.65 of the Madison General Ordinances to regulate the sale of pets in retail pet stores.

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt Alternate. Meeting record for Nov 25, 2025

  • 90169: SUBSTITUTE: Creating Section 23.202 of the Madison General Ordinances related to Age Restrictions on Hemp-Derived THC Products.

    Their vote: No. The council's action: Adopt Alternate. Meeting record for Nov 25, 2025

  • Untitled item

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Call the Question. Meeting record for Nov 11, 2025

Show 15 more recent votes
  • 90249: 2026 Executive Operating Budget

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt. Meeting record for Nov 11, 2025

  • 90249: 2026 Executive Operating Budget

    Their vote: No. The council's action: Adopt. Meeting record for Nov 11, 2025

  • 89347: Authorizing execution of a sole source $150,000 contract with Downtown Madison Inc. for the preparation of a Downtown Economic Investment Strategy (District 2, District 4, District 6, District 8, and District 13).

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Reconsider. Meeting record for Oct 7, 2025

  • 89779: SUBSTITUTE: Extending the contract between the City of Madison and MACH Onehealth, Inc. dba Madison Street Medicine to provide those services and extend currently allocated funding through April 2026, at an additional cost of $0 dollars from the City of Madison, and authorizes the use of up to $100,000 of additional funds from Dane County to pay for those services

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt Substitute. Meeting record for Sep 16, 2025

  • 88846: AMENDED: Creating Subdivision 8.35(3)(f) of the Madison General Ordinances to allow for construction and change in the legal status of certain lands associated with the Madison LakeWay Project.

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt As Amended. Meeting record for Jul 15, 2025

  • 88846: AMENDED: Creating Subdivision 8.35(3)(f) of the Madison General Ordinances to allow for construction and change in the legal status of certain lands associated with the Madison LakeWay Project.

    Their vote: No. The council's action: Refer. Meeting record for Jul 15, 2025

  • 88846: AMENDED: Creating Subdivision 8.35(3)(f) of the Madison General Ordinances to allow for construction and change in the legal status of certain lands associated with the Madison LakeWay Project.

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt the Following Amendment(s). Meeting record for Jul 15, 2025

  • 88477: Vacating and discontinuing a portion of public street right-of-way of University Bay Drive; realigning and accepting a Permanent Limited Easement for public street purposes; and amending the City of Madison Official Map, all to allow for the future relocation of University Bay Drive and construction of the Lakeshore Nature Preserve Frautschi Center. Located in part of the Southeast 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 and part of the Southwest 1/4 of the Northeast 1/4 of Section 16, Township 7 North, Range 9 East, City of Madison, Dane County, Wisconsin. (District 5)

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt and Close the Public Hearing. Meeting record for Jul 15, 2025

  • 83669: SECOND SUBSTITUTE: Amending Section 38.05(9)(f) of the Madison General Ordinances related to geographic limitations on Class A and Class B license applications considered by the Common Council after adoption of this ordinance for purposes of regulating density of such alcohol beverage licenses.

    Their vote: No. The council's action: Adopt. Meeting record for Jul 1, 2025

  • 85327: ALTERNATE: Amending Section 5.20(3)(a)3. of the Madison General Ordinances to modify the nomination process to the Police Civilian Oversight Board to align with current procedures for seeking applications.

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Re-refer. Meeting record for Jul 1, 2025

  • 83669: SECOND SUBSTITUTE: Amending Section 38.05(9)(f) of the Madison General Ordinances related to geographic limitations on Class A and Class B license applications considered by the Common Council after adoption of this ordinance for purposes of regulating density of such alcohol beverage licenses.

    Their vote: No. The council's action: Adopt the Following Amendment(s). Meeting record for Jul 1, 2025

  • 83477: SUBSTITUTE: Creating Section 28.022-00672 of the Madison General Ordinances to change the zoning of property located at 6610-6706 Old Sauk Road from SR-C1 (Suburban Residential-Consistent 1) District and SR-C3 (Suburban Residential-Consistent 3) District to TR-U2 (Traditional Residential-Urban 2) District. (District 19)

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt. Meeting record for Jun 17, 2025

  • 86169: Authorizing the eventual forgiveness of $1,613,365 of debt held by Madison Ice Inc. for the Madison Ice Arena (725 Forward Drive) and Hartmeyer Ice Arena (1810 and 1834 Commercial Avenue), authorizing the termination of existing land contracts for both ice arenas with Madison Ice Hartmeyer, LLC and Madison Ice MIA, LLC (Madison Ice, Inc.), authorizing the fee simple sale of Hartmeyer Ice Arena to East Madison Ice Collective and the fee simple sale of Madison Ice Arena to Madison Ice, Inc. for $1, authorizing a fundraising requirement of approximately $3 million by East Madison Ice Collective for capital improvements to Hartmeyer Ice Arena, and authorizing additional terms related to the renegotiation of the City’s relationship to the ice arenas (District 12 and District 19).

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt with the Recommendation(s). Meeting record for Jan 14, 2025

  • 85413: Hearing re: Ethics Board Complaint filed by Emily Samson against Shadayra Kilfoy-Flores

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Adopt. Meeting record for Jan 14, 2025

  • 86169: Authorizing the eventual forgiveness of $1,613,365 of debt held by Madison Ice Inc. for the Madison Ice Arena (725 Forward Drive) and Hartmeyer Ice Arena (1810 and 1834 Commercial Avenue), authorizing the termination of existing land contracts for both ice arenas with Madison Ice Hartmeyer, LLC and Madison Ice MIA, LLC (Madison Ice, Inc.), authorizing the fee simple sale of Hartmeyer Ice Arena to East Madison Ice Collective and the fee simple sale of Madison Ice Arena to Madison Ice, Inc. for $1, authorizing a fundraising requirement of approximately $3 million by East Madison Ice Collective for capital improvements to Hartmeyer Ice Arena, and authorizing additional terms related to the renegotiation of the City’s relationship to the ice arenas (District 12 and District 19).

    Their vote: Aye. The council's action: Call the Question. Meeting record for Jan 14, 2025

From the Madison Common Council's own records, the latest from Apr 21, 2026.